The short version
Macoun and Empire share a parent in McIntosh. Macoun is sweeter, richer and best eaten fresh. Empire is firmer, stores exceptionally well and handles snacking, baking and sauce equally.
One parent, two different apples
Macoun sits at an 8 of 10 on our sweetness scale and Empire at a 5. Macoun is the richer, juicier apple. Empire is the more versatile one.
The difference comes from the other side of each cross. Macoun is McIntosh and Jersey Black. Empire is McIntosh and Red Delicious, which gave it a firmer structure.
Macoun and Empire at a glance
| Attribute | Macoun | Empire |
|---|---|---|
| Sweetness | 8 of 10 | 5 of 10 |
| Parentage | McIntosh and Jersey Black | McIntosh and Red Delicious |
| Flavor | Rich, aromatic, sweet-tart | Balanced sweet-tart, hint of melon |
| Texture | Crisp, tender, exceptionally juicy | Firm, crisp, creamy white flesh |
| Appearance | Deep red to dark purple over green | Deep red, can be squat |
| Harvest | Around October 5 | Around September 22 |
| Storage | Available October to May | Exceptional |
| Best for | Fresh eating, salads, cheese boards | Baking, sauces, crisps, snacking |
How they taste
Macoun is especially beloved in New York and across the Northeast. It inherited the aromatic McIntosh flavor and brings a sweeter, richer taste with an exceptionally juicy bite. Crisp, sweet-tart and fragrant, it is an apple people wait all year to find.
Empire was developed in New York, the Empire State, by crossing two American classics. The flavor is balanced sweet-tart with a hint of melon, and the flesh is crisp and creamy white.
Which one to use where
Macoun is a fresh-eating apple. It is at its best out of hand, sliced into salads or paired with a sharp cheese.
Empire does everything. It works as a snack, holds its shape in a pie or crisp and cooks into applesauce. It also stores exceptionally well, which is why processors favor it for fresh slices, sauce and juice.
When each one arrives
Empire harvests around September 22. Macoun follows about two weeks later, around October 5, and is available into May.
For a few weeks in October you can put both on the table and taste the family resemblance for yourself.
Reach for Macoun if
You want a sweet, rich apple to eat fresh, you are building a cheese board, or you love the McIntosh aroma and want more sweetness with it.
Reach for Empire if
You want one apple for snacking, baking and sauce, you need slices that hold their shape, or you want an apple that keeps well.
Start with the parent
Both of these apples trace back to McIntosh. See how each one compares with the original in Empire vs McIntosh.
Macoun and Empire, answered
Are Macoun and Empire related?
Yes. Both are McIntosh crosses. Macoun came from McIntosh and Jersey Black, and Empire from McIntosh and Red Delicious.
Which is sweeter, Macoun or Empire?
Macoun, at an 8 of 10 on our sweetness scale against Empire at a 5.
Can I substitute Empire for Macoun?
For fresh eating, yes. Empire is a sensible stand-in for Macoun, especially in the Northeast. Expect a firmer bite and less sweetness.
Which one is better for baking?
Empire. It holds its shape in a pie or crisp. Macoun is at its best eaten fresh.
Which one stores better?
Empire stores exceptionally well, which is one reason processors like it for slices, sauce and juice.



