Macoun vs McIntosh

October 5, 2026
Riveridge Apple Comparison Macoun vs McIntosh

The short version

Macoun is McIntosh crossed with Jersey Black. It kept the McIntosh aroma and added a sweeter, richer flavor. McIntosh is tarter, arrives a month earlier and is still the best base for fresh cider.

Five points apart on sweetness

Macoun sits at an 8 of 10 on our sweetness scale and McIntosh at a 3. That is the widest gap you will find between a parent and its offspring in our lineup.

Both are aromatic, tender and very juicy, which is the family resemblance. Macoun is the one to eat out of hand. McIntosh is the one to press and cook.

Macoun and McIntosh at a glance

Attribute Macoun McIntosh
Sweetness 8 of 10 3 of 10
Flavor Rich, aromatic, sweet-tart Tangy, tart, strongly aromatic
Texture Crisp, tender, exceptionally juicy Tender, ultra juicy white flesh
Appearance Deep red to dark purple over green Squat, pink-red over green
Harvest Around October 5 Around September 5
Availability October to May September to June
Best for Fresh eating, salads, cheese boards Cider, sauce, baking blends

How they taste

Macoun is the kind of apple people wait all year to find, especially in New York and across the Northeast. It inherited the McIntosh aroma and brings a sweeter, richer taste with an exceptionally juicy bite. The deep red, sometimes almost purple skin makes it easy to spot.

McIntosh is the apple most people picture when they hear the word. Tangy and tart, tender, extremely juicy, with an aroma distinctive enough that candles are made to imitate it. It was discovered in Ontario in the early 1800s, and cooler climates bring its flavor out fully.

Which one to use where

Macoun is at its best fresh. Eat it out of hand, slice it into a salad or pair it with a sharp cheese. The flavor is the whole point, so there is no reason to cook it away.

McIntosh earns its place in the kitchen. It is the go-to base for fresh cider, thanks to its balance of sweetness and acidity and its volume of juice. It also cooks down into excellent applesauce.

When each one arrives

McIntosh harvests around September 5 and ships through June, one of the longer seasons of any variety we handle. Macoun follows about a month later, around October 5.

If you see Macoun in the fall, buy it then. Its following is built on a season people look forward to.

Reach for Macoun if

You want the McIntosh aroma with far more sweetness, you are building a cheese board or a salad, or you want a fall apple worth seeking out.

Reach for McIntosh if

You are making cider or applesauce, you like a tart apple, or you want that classic aroma from early September on.

McIntosh has a big family

Macoun is not the only McIntosh cross in the bin. Empire came from McIntosh and Red Delicious, and Cortland from McIntosh and Ben Davis. See how they compare in Empire vs McIntosh and McIntosh vs Cortland.

Browse all varieties

Macoun and McIntosh, answered

What are Macoun’s parent varieties?

Macoun is a cross between McIntosh and Jersey Black. It inherited the aromatic McIntosh flavor and added a sweeter, richer taste.

Which is sweeter, Macoun or McIntosh?

Macoun, by a wide margin. It sits at an 8 of 10 on our sweetness scale against McIntosh at a 3.

What is a good substitute for Macoun?

McIntosh is the first recommendation because it is one of Macoun’s parents and shares its aromatic, juicy character. Empire also makes sense, especially in the Northeast.

What is the best apple for cider?

McIntosh is the go-to base. It has an ideal balance of sweetness and acidity plus plenty of juice, which makes for a well-rounded cider.

How do I recognize a Macoun?

Look for deep red to dark purple skin over a green background. The color is darker than a McIntosh, which runs pink-red over green.

Written By

Riveridge Produce Marketing

We grow, pack and ship apples, sweet cherries, cider and Midwest vegetables from 150 family farms. Everything here comes from people who do this for a living.

Have a question?

Our team has spent decades in orchards and likes being asked.

Keep Reading

More from the orchard.

Macoun vs Empire

Macoun vs Empire

Macoun and Empire are both McIntosh crosses with New York roots. Macoun is the sweeter fresh-eating apple, and Empire is the firmer all-purpose one.

read more
Ludacrisp vs Honeycrisp

Ludacrisp vs Honeycrisp

Ludacrisp is the sweeter apple with a tropical, fruit-punch flavor. Honeycrisp has the famous explosive crunch. Here is how the newcomer compares with the favorite.

read more

Stay Fresh

Harvest updates, when there is news.

New varieties, season timing and what is coming off the trees. We send it when there is something worth sending.