The short version
Jonagold is Jonathan crossed with Golden Delicious, which explains both the name and the flavor. Jonathan is sharply tart and a good stand-in for Granny Smith. Jonagold is large, sweet with a honeyed edge, and probably the single best pie apple Michigan grows.
Not interchangeable, despite the names
Jonathan is a 1 of 10 on our sweetness scale, the tartest apple in our lineup. Jonagold is a 7. That is a six point spread between a parent and its child, and it comes entirely from the Golden Delicious side of the cross.
So despite the names, these are not interchangeable. One is a sharp, bright cooking apple. The other is a big, honeyed, everything apple.
Jonathan and Jonagold at a glance
| Attribute | Jonathan | Jonagold |
|---|---|---|
| Sweetness | 1 of 10 | 7 of 10 |
| Flavor | Tart and tangy, bright acidity | Sweet-tart with a hint of honey |
| Size | Medium to large | Notably large |
| Appearance | Strong crimson red | Golden yellow with red blush |
| Texture | Firm, juicy white-yellow flesh | Firm, cooks up tender |
| Michigan harvest | Around September 22 | Around September 24 |
| Availability | September through February | September through April |
| Best for | Sauce, condiments, caramel apples | Pies, crisps, slices, snacking |
How they taste
Jonathan is among the most tart and tangy varieties grown in Michigan. Cool northern nights sharpen the acidity rather than dulling it. The flesh is firm and juicy, the color is a deep crimson, and the size makes it a natural for caramel apples.
Jonagold tastes like what it is, a compromise between a tart parent and a sweet one. Honey-tart is the usual description and it fits. Aromatic, large, crisp, and juicy enough to eat out of hand without thinking of it as a cooking apple.
Which one to bake with
If you only get to pick one apple for a pie, pick Jonagold. It brings the structure and texture of Golden Delicious together with the sweet-tart punch of Jonathan, and it bakes beautifully. The size helps too, because fewer apples means less peeling.
Jonathan is a blender. On its own in a pie it can read as too sharp, but a few Jonathan slices mixed into a Jonagold or Ida Red pie lift the whole thing. Where Jonathan really shines is applesauce, scalloped apple dishes and condiments, anywhere you want acidity to cut through sugar or fat.
The Granny Smith question
Granny Smith is not grown in Michigan. It needs a longer, warmer growing season than the state gives it, which is why almost every green apple in a Michigan store came from somewhere else.
If a recipe calls for Granny Smith and you want to stay local, use Jonathan. It is not green, but the tart, tangy profile does the same work in a pie, a sauce or a salad.
Reach for Jonathan if
A recipe calls for Granny Smith, you are making applesauce or a condiment, you want acidity to balance a sweet dish, or you are making caramel apples.
Reach for Jonagold if
You are making one pie and want one apple, you want a large apple that peels quickly, or you want something that works equally well baked, sliced or eaten fresh.
Two days apart in the orchard
Jonathan comes off around September 22 and Jonagold around September 24. In practice they harvest together, so if you find one at a Michigan market in the fall, the other is usually within reach.
Jonathan and Jonagold, answered
Is Jonagold the same as Jonathan?
No. Jonagold is a cross of Jonathan and Golden Delicious. It inherited the name from one parent and most of its sweetness from the other.
If I had to choose one apple for a pie, which should I pick?
Jonagold. It combines the structure of Golden Delicious with the sweet-tart punch of Jonathan, and it bakes beautifully on its own without blending.
Granny Smith is not grown in Michigan. What is a good local alternative?
Jonathan. It is not green, but its tart, tangy flavor works anywhere you would use a Granny Smith.
Which apple is bigger?
Jonagold, and noticeably so. That size makes it convenient for baking and it is a common choice for commercial slicing operations.
Which one stores longer?
Jonagold. It ships September through April, while Jonathan generally runs September through February.



